Chicago Film Critics Association Awards
| YEAR | AWARD | OUTCOME | PICS |
| 2001 | Best Actor
for: You Can Count On Me |
nominated | – |
Chlotrudis Awards
| YEAR | AWARD | OUTCOME | PICS |
| 2004 | Best Actor
for: My Life Without Me |
nominated | – |
| 2001 | Best Actor for: You Can Count On Me |
nominated | – |
independent spirit Awards
| YEAR | AWARD | OUTCOME | PICS |
| 2001 | Best Male Lead
for: You Can Count On Me |
nominated | – |
los angeles Film Critics Association Awards
| YEAR | AWARD | OUTCOME | PICS |
| 2001 | New Generation
for: You Can Count On Me |
WON | – |
MTV Movie Awards
| YEAR | AWARD | OUTCOME | PICS |
| 2005 | Best Musical Performance (Thriller Dance)
for: 13 Going On 30 |
nominated | – |
montréal word film festival
| YEAR | AWARD | OUTCOME | PICS |
| 2000 | Best Actor
for: You Can Count On Me |
WON | – |
teen choice awards
| YEAR | AWARD | OUTCOME | PICS |
| 2004 | Choice Movie Actor (Comedy), Choice Movie Chemistry, Choice Movie Liplock
for: 13 going on 30 |
Nominated | – |
